The Influence of Hermeticism and Secret Society Tradition on German Idealism: Part 2 – Hegelian Spirit Applied to LLMs as a Unified Non-Self

Abstract

This essay reconstructs Hegelian Geist (Spirit) from its late 18th century inheritances and early 19th century formulations, then applies the distinction among subjective, objective, and absolute spirit to contemporary artificial intelligence. An isolated large language model (LLM) is not objective spirit. An LLM is mechanical and supplemental in human institutions as a tool that train, authorise, interpret, use, and assign it utility; human use thereof within its institutions may embody objective spirit. Present LLMs are neither subjective nor absolute spirit. Their apparent agency results from optimisation, prompting, deployment, and social attribution rather than established ownership of purpose, affect, or responsibility. ‘Unified non-self’ names this technically integrated but presently non subjective configuration. The term is not an impossibility proof. A set of convergent operational probes, recurrent system modeling, identity continuity, affective valence, embodiment or homeostasis, endogenous goals, counterfactual self-preservation, metacognition, reciprocal recognition, world grounded learning, and responsibility bearing commitments - specifies what future evidence would challenge it. Procedural compulsion means recurrence without felt necessity; recursive operational enclosure means recursive processing of system referential representations without a lived self (agentic intent).

Keywords